Best Sugar Free Pumpkin Pie - CopyKat Recipes (2024)

Sugar Free Pumpkin pie is great for diabetics and anyone wanting to reduce their sugar intake. The filling is creamy and perfectly flavored. This pumpkin pie without sugar is perfect for Thanksgiving.

This post contains affiliate links. As an Amazon Associate, I earn from qualifying purchases.

Diabetic Pumpkin Pie

Growing up my father was diabetic and this was one of his favorite desserts. This sugar-free pumpkin pie recipe is from the archive of my grandmother, Ethel Eynard.

Now, you can make this delicious sugar-free pumpkin pie for your holiday table or any time you feel like eating pumpkin pie. It’s great if you’re trying to cut down on refined sugar or have a person with diabetes in your family.

A no sugar added pumpkin pie doesn’t mean you sacrifice taste. Enjoy this delicious take on regular pumpkin pie. Even those on restricted diets should be able to enjoy a good piece of pie once in a while.

Why This Is the Best Sugar-Free Pumpkin Pie You Must Try

If you are looking for a way to cut down on sugar but still want to enjoy a slice of pumpkin pie, this best sugar-free pumpkin pie recipe allows you to do both.

The richest orange colors and warming spices mean pumpkin pie is the perfect dessert for your Thanksgiving table. This healthy pumpkin pie tastes as delicious as it looks, and it’s so nice to have a healthier option. You won’t miss the sugar one bit!

One slice of traditional pumpkin pie has about 25 grams of sugar. To keep this in perspective, the American Heart Association recommends that men consume no more than 36 grams of sugar per day and women no more than 25 grams. There you go, ladies! One slice of regular pumpkin pie, and you’ve blown your whole allowance!

Sugar-Free Pumpkin Pie Recipe – Ingredients You Will Need

This diabetic pumpkin pie is made with pumpkin puree plus some basic ingredients and spices. Here’s your ingredient list:

• Pastry pie shell
• Pumpkin puree
• Eggs
• Evaporated milk
• Sugar Twin brown sugar
• Cinnamon
• Ginger
• Cloves
• Salt

How to Make Sugar Free Pumpkin Pie

1. Place all the filling ingredients in a large bowl.

2. Mix the filling ingredients until smooth and well-combined.

3. Pour the filling mixture into a pie shell.

4. Bake for 10 minutes at 425°F.
5. Reduce temperature to 350°F and bake for 30 minutes.

Notes on Sugar Substitutes

Sugar substitutes vary in sweetness – they can be more or less sweet than actual sugar. So read the directions and add your sweetener carefully. Taste the filling before putting it into the pie crust and adjust the sweetener to your taste.

• Here’s a helpful sweetener to sugar conversion chart.

Bear in mind that some artificial sweeteners have an aftertaste that you or others may dislike, so it might be a good idea to experiment beforehand with a sweetener you haven’t tried before. Here are some more pointers:

• If you can’t find brown Sugar Twin, look for Swerve brown sugar or otherbrown sugar substitutessuch as brown granular Monk Fruit sweetener.
• Allulosewill contribute a bit of burnt sugar and caramel taste to the pumpkin pie filling and a caramelized look to the top.
• Read the labels, e.g., make sure Stevia has not been combined with regular sugar.

No Sugar Added Pumpkin Pie Recipe Variations

To keep this pumpkin pie recipe sugar-free overall, look for asugar-free pie crustor make your own crust and leave out the sugar or swap for an artificial sweetener. You could also make a crustless sugar-free pumpkin pie that’s more like a custard. Here’s a pie crust recipe that makes a perfect pastry crust in a pie pan every time.

• Try coconut milk or unsweetened almond milk creamer instead of evaporated milk for a dairy-free filling.
• Instead of individual spices, feel free to use 2 teaspoons of pumpkin pie spice instead.
• Add 1/4 teaspoon of nutmeg or 1 teaspoon of vanilla extract for more flavors in the filling.
• Add 1 tablespoon of sugar-free maple syrup for a nice fall flavor touch.
• For a gluten-free pie, use a gluten-free pie shell or make one with gluten-free flour or almond flour.

Advice on Buying Pumpkin Puree

This recipe calls for pumpkin puree, not pumpkin pie filling. Pumpkin puree is simply cooked types of squash that have been mashed. Pumpkin pie filling, on the other hand, is pureed pumpkin flesh mixed with spices and sweetener (most likely sugar). You need pumpkin puree for this sugar-free pumpkin pie recipe.

On many pumpkin puree brand labels, you will not find “pumpkin” listed, but you will find pumpkin flavoring and squash. Ok, so pumpkin is a squash but so are butternut, yellow, zucchini, and many others. But do you want squash pie or pumpkin pie?

How to Make Your Own Pumpkin Puree

With just a bit more work, you can get a greatly improved pie this way:

1. Buy baking pumpkins and clean and quarter them.
2. Place the pumpkin pieces in a baking dish and sprinkle over some pumpkin pie spice, cinnamon, a small amount of ground cloves, some brown sugar (or sugar substitute), and a few dabs of butter.
3. Cover with foil and bake at 350°F until the pumpkin is soft but not overcooked.
4. Mash the pumpkin thoroughly; otherwise, your pie may be a little stringy.

Understand that the color and texture of your “real” pumpkin pie will be somewhat different from a “squash” pie, but your taste buds will thank you.

Should You Pre-Bake the Crust?

If you are not making a crustless sugar-free pumpkin pie and are using a pastry crust, you may want to pre-bake (or partially pre-bake) so it doesn’t get soggy once you add the filling.

Because your pie is in the oven for a long time to allow for the pumpkin filling to set, you shouldcover the crust edge after about 30 minutes, so it does not burn. You can use apie crust protector shieldor make your own shield by cutting a “halo” out of aluminum foil – click here for a helpful video.

How to Prevent Cracks in Your No Sugar Added Pumpkin Pie

The secret to getting no cracks in your no sugar added pumpkin pie is not to overbake it. It’s a custard – in some ways similar to cheesecake. So, take it out of the oven when it’s still jiggly.

Overbaking will cause cracks and affect the texture. However, if you do end up with cracks, you can always cover them with whipped cream and no one will notice!

To reduce the chance of cracking your low-carb pumpkin pie, you can bake the pie in a water bath.

Toppings for Your Sugar-Free Pumpkin Pie

• Serve with sugar-free whipped cream for a classic holiday treat.
• You can also trysugar-free coconut cream.
• There are plenty of pumpkin pie toppings you may never have thought of! You will have to substitute artificial sweeteners for the ones made with sugar.

How to Store Diabetic Pumpkin Pie

You can prepare this easy pumpkin pie at least three days ahead. Once cooled, cover and refrigerate.

This pumpkin pie can also be frozen for up to one month. Thaw the frozen pie in the refrigerator overnight.

Popular Pumpkin Recipes

• Air Fry Pumpkin Seeds
• Double Layer Pumpkin Pie
• Homemade Pumpkin Pie Spice
• Olive Garden Pumpkin Cheesecake
• Pumpkin Custard
• Pumpkin Dump Cake
• Pumpkin Muffins with Cake Mix
• Pumpkin Spice Pancakes
• Starbucks Pumpkin Bread Recipe
• Starbucks Pumpkin Spice Latte

Favorite Thanksgiving Desserts

• Cherry Pineapple Dump Cake
• Lemon Lush
• Old Fashioned Chocolate Pie

Check out more of my easy pie recipes and the best Thanksgiving dessert recipes here on CopyKat!

This recipe is from the archive of my grandmother, Ethel Eynard. Jefferson City, MO.1988